With the imminent arrival of January, almost half of the top 50 free agents have already secured new deals, ranging from Juan Soto’s massive $765 million contract with the Mets to Danny Jansen’s one-year, $8.5 million agreement with the Rays. However, there are still notable talents available in the market for major-league teams to consider adding to their rosters. Discussions about which options are the best fit for each position are likely underway in front offices across the league.
As we anticipate another wave of deals in the new year, let’s take a look at three pairs of free agents from the top-50 list who teams may be evaluating as potential upgrades in the infield, outfield, and starting rotation – along with our preferred choices.
Gleyber Torres or Ha-Seong Kim?
Shusterman: The debate between Kim and Torres would have been more exciting a year ago when both were ranked among the top-10 second basemen in MLB. However, both players faced challenges in the past season, leading to uncertainties as they entered free agency. Kim showed promising contact skills and a keen eye for walks but struggled with power following a shoulder injury. On the other hand, Torres had a solid 2023 season but faced defensive and baserunning issues. Despite Kim’s potential, his recovery from surgery raises concerns about his impact in the upcoming season. I believe Torres’ offensive potential makes him a better short-term investment, especially considering his age and the possibility of re-entering free agency in the near future.
Dorsey: Kim brings a unique skill set to the free-agent market, showcasing improvement in each season and versatility in playing multiple infield positions. While Torres may have offensive potential, Kim’s well-rounded abilities and defensive prowess make him an attractive option at an affordable price.
Teoscar Hernández or Anthony Santander?
Shusterman: Hernández boasts exceptional power but struggles with strikeouts, while Santander has shown consistent slugging ability from both sides of the plate. Despite both players’ offensive strengths, I lean slightly towards Santander due to his switch-hitting capability and better plate discipline.
Dorsey: While both players have offensive strengths, Hernández’s ability to produce consistently across different lineups and leagues gives him the edge in my opinion.
Justin Verlander or Max Scherzer?
Shusterman: Both Verlander and Scherzer are future Hall of Famers coming off challenging seasons. While both face durability concerns, I lean towards Verlander due to his adaptability and recent positive performance.
Dorsey: Scherzer may have dealt with injuries, but his effectiveness on the mound makes him a better gamble at this stage of their careers.
Overall, the free-agent market presents intriguing options across various positions, providing teams with opportunities to enhance their rosters as they prepare for the upcoming season.